by Ruby Vox

I’m sorry, Jordan Knight. I meant to see you around my birthday. I really did. I was so going to spend a night with you, basking in the wonder of how you’ll be loving me (forever), listening to your falsetto with the same rapt attention I gave you when I was ten. But then something—someone—happened, and now I have to cancel. I know you’ll understand.
I have to fly to New York on October 21st, hop a train to the Village, and see Caleb Hawley again.
It’s not your fault, Jordan. You and I met at such a young age. I think it’s time to admit we’ve each gone our own way. It’s okay. I’ve moved on, and you can, too. We’ll both be better for it.
Just so you know, I wasn’t planning on breaking our date for Caleb. We met at a tiny music café in Excelsior last week, and he changed the way I look at life. It’s kind of weird.
At first, I wasn’t really that impressed. I mean, he looked like something straight out of a Metallica show circa 1993. He was only 22, and initially his cheeky demeanor suggested that this was going to be a long night of listening to some pompous kid crank out Pearl Jam covers. “Been there, done that,” I thought to myself. How foolish I was.
I’d arrived early enough to see him sound-check, and the moment he picked up his guitar, the sun started shining more brightly. With a voice that he picked up at the intersection of Stevie Wonder and Dr. Dog and a style somewhere between Broadway and Sufjan Stevens, my interest was definitely piqued.
He passed out a piece of paper that contained every song he was willing to play that evening by name, giving them each Fan-O-Meter and Caleb-O-Meter ratings. It was delightful to watch the audience pick all the songs he hated.
He played a cover of JT’s “Senorita” that followed the oldest rule of covers in the books: pick an over-the-top popular song, and render it unrecognizable in a good way. It wasn’t the least bit cutesy. He turned it into a remarkable performance.
I’d like to see you try that, Jordan Knight.
Caleb’s songwriting was astounding. Lyrically, he revealed his youth a bit, oversimplifying complex issues at times. But his premise was good and his cleverness made up for it. His musicianship was unparalleled. There’s no one else like that.
I’ve been waiting for you to grow with me, Jordan. When NKOTB released Step By Step, I thought, “Okay. I’m now officially a teen. Maybe they’ll make music that appeals to me.”
No dice.
When you released your pathetic solo album, I pretended not to notice. But I did. I was so damned hopeful that you would come through with something that sounded like real music. Nope.
And then you did it. You got back together with the boys and launched a reunion tour.
But it’s not 1988 anymore, and to be honest, it wasn’t even cute then.
It took Caleb to show me the light, Jordan, and I’ll be thanking him by spending October 21st watching him cover your songs at The Bitter End. Brilliantly.